Does anyone really watch the Emmys anymore. Personally, I haven’t watched since the telecast that aired a few months after September 11, which really was a great telecast featuring a heartwarming tribute to all those who lose their lives on that day. Of course, just because I won’t be watching doesn’t mean I’m not sharing my unwanted opinion.
Lead Actor–Comedy: Of the shows with nominees I only watch two: King of Queens and Two and a Half Men. While I enjoy both those shows, along with Kevin James and Charlie Sheen, neither are Emmy worthy actors. I don’t watch the other shows, but what I’ve seen of Steve Carell in movies and clips from his show he’s certainly the most deserving.
Lead Actress–Comedy: Stockard Channing and Debra Messing? Really? Of the actresses nominated my personal favorite is Lisa Kudrow for The Comeback. She played a character that was totally different from the Buffet sisters she’s most well-known for playing. HBO canceled this series too quickly and showed no support for what could have become a very popular, quirky series. If it can’t be Kudrow, then it should be Jane Kaczmarek. Who should have been here and won? It’s past time Lauren Graham got some attention from the old geezers at the Academy. Also, Alyson Hannigan of How I Met Your Mother deserves some attention, maybe not win, but at least get noticed.
Lead Actor–Drama: As much as I loved The West Wing and as much as I thought their final season was their best in years, this should really be a race between Kiefer Sutherland and Dennis Leary. Of the two, I think Leary is the most deserving; and I don’t like the show. The person who should have been nominated and won in this category is Edward James Olmos for his exceptional portrayal of Commander Adama on Battlestar Galactica.
Lead Actress–Drama: Hands down, the winner of this category should be Kyra Sedgewick. Hands down! As much as liked the misspelled Commander in Chief (it should be Commander-in-Chief), the show went downhill after Bochco took over and Davis’ performances were lackluster. Also, if there is one good thing about the cancellation of The West Wing it’s that we won’t have to endure the never ending nominations of Allison Janney. This was the weakest season yet for Janney’s character and she sure wasn’t in it enough to be nominated as Lead Actress. Again, I have to return to Battlestar Galactica and Mary McDonnell’s beautifully portrayed President Roslin; by far, more deserving than Allison Janney or Geena Davis.
Supporting Actor–Comedy: Other than Will & Grace and Two and a Half Men I don’t watch any of nominated shows. All I can say is Jon Cryer and Sean Hayes don’t deserve them. Neil Patrick Harris of How I Met Your Mother would have been a better and more deserving choice than either of these two.
Supporting Actress–Comedy: Again, I don’t watch most of these shows. All I can say is no on Megan Mullaly and hell no on Alfre Woodard for her disastrous performance on Desperate Housewives. Don’t get me wrong, both are very, very good at what they do, but Mullally doesn’t deserve it and Woodard’s plot was a major reason why Season 2 of DH sucked. Alexis Bledel and/or Kelly Bishop of Gilmore Girls would have been much better choices.
Supporting Actor–Drama: For me, this would come down to Gregory Itzin and Alan Alda with Itzin being the most deserving of the two. Alda was great as the likable Republican candidate on West Wing’s final season, but Itzin’s crazed performance as the power-hungry president on 24 was the highlight of the season.
Supporting Actress–Drama: Again, it comes down to two people for me: Chandra Wilson for Grey’s Anatomy and Jean Smart for 24. I really enjoyed Smart’s performance as the manic first lady on 24, probably her best work since Designing Women, but I think Wilson is the better of two. There’s no chance in hell she would have won, but Tricia Helfer, "Number Six" on Battlestar Galactica, gave some of the finest performances I’ve seen this year; especially in the two Pegasus episodes where she was pulling double-duty. For that matter, Katee Sackhoff’s "Starbuck" was damn worthy, as well.
Outstanding Comedy Series: Other than the fact that Two and a Half Men doesn’t deserve it, I can’t say much since I don’t watch any of the other shows.
Outstanding Drama Series: Please, oh please, don’t let it be The West Wing. Again, season seven was fantastic, but the show has already won more Emmys in this category than it rightfully deserved. My personal choice here is Grey’s Anatomy. The series really came into its own in season two and became a better show than its lead-in, Desperate Housewives. Who damn well deserved to be nominated and win in this category? Battlestar Galactica is by far one of the finest drama series on television, equally if not better than all the shows nominated in this category.